In the future, climate-friendly hydrogen will replace fossil fuels in the mobility sector, in industry and in municipal energy projects around the world. In Germany alone, the production capacity of green hydrogen is to be increased to ten gigawatts by 2030. In order to accelerate the international hydrogen ramp-up and quickly build up sufficient production capacity for green hydrogen, it is important to use the right technology. We look at the advantages and disadvantages of alkaline electrolysis and PEM electrolysis.

Green hydrogen is the “fuel of the energy transition”. Unlike fossil fuels, no CO2 emissions are caused during its production and also later during its use. It is important that the energy for hydrogen production comes from renewable energy sources such as photovoltaic or wind power plants. Renewable energies, green hydrogen and its derivatives such as ammonia and methanol are particularly essential for the energy transition in industry and for heavy-duty transportation, such as trucks, shipping and aviation.

Electrolysis, the splitting of water into hydrogen and oxygen using electricity, has proven to be the most suitable process for the production of green hydrogen. There are various electrolysis processes: PEM electrolysis based on proton exchange membrane (PEM) technology, and alkaline electrolysis (AEL). Those are the most mature processes. Other electrolysis processes include high-temperature electrolysis and AEM water electrolysis (AEM stands for Anion Exchange Membrane).

While AEM and high-temperature electrolysis have not yet reached full technical maturity and are only operated in pilot projects or on a small scale, alkaline electrolysis and PEM electrolysis are particularly important for the rapid hydrogen ramp-up. PEM electrolysis in particular is one of the most important processes for industrial-scale hydrogen production from renewable energy sources.

What happens in the electrolyzer?

Hydrogen production by electrolysis was described as early as 1800 and is one of the oldest electrochemical processes. Hydrogen electrolysis uses electricity to split water into hydrogen and oxygen: Two water molecules (2 H2O) each become two hydrogen molecules (2 H2) and one oxygen molecule (O2).

Electrolysis requires two electrodes, an anode and a cathode, direct current and a liquid electrolyte for alkaline electrolysis or an acidic solid electrolyte membrane for PEM electrolysis. The use of direct current separates the water into its components. The hydrogen collects at the negatively charged cathode and the oxygen at the positively charged anode.

Alkaline electrolysis

Alkaline electrolysis is almost 100 years old and is the oldest technology available on a large scale. Alkaline electrolysis uses potassium hydroxide (KOH) as the electrolyte. There is a diaphragm between the cathode and anode that is impermeable to the product gases hydrogen and oxygen, preventing them from mixing. It also prevents the formation of explosive gases. The negatively charged hydroxide ions can pass through the diaphragm and move to the anode. The potassium hydroxide solution is constantly circulated, ensuring continuous degassing.

However, alkaline electrolyzers can be less  dynamic in their response to load changes. For this reason, alkaline electrolysis has some disadvantages when coupled with renewable electricity sources: For example, the achievable gas purity decreases in partial load operation and degradation problems occur. One reason for this is the relatively sluggish electrolyte cycle. In addition, alkaline electrolysis requires a longer cold start time.

PEM electrolysis

PEM electrolysis was developed about 50 years ago. This makes it the newer technology, but like alkaline electrolysis, it is already commercially available on an industrial scale. Instead of a liquid electrolyte, PEM electrolysis uses a solid polymer electrolyte, the proton-conducting “proton exchange membrane” or “polymer electrolyte membrane” (PEM).

PEM electrolysis is essentially the reverse of the fuel cell principle. A PEM electrolyzer is used to convert water into hydrogen and oxygen. The process takes place in the electrolysis stack, the heart of the electrolyzer. During electrolysis, positively charged hydrogen ions (protons) move through the gas-tight membrane to the cathode. There they combine with an electron to form hydrogen molecules. At the same time, oxygen is separated on the anode side, which can be reused depending on the system technology. The gas-impermeable membrane ensures that the electrolysis products hydrogen and oxygen do not mix. Unlike alkaline electrolysis, the PEM electrolyzer requires only high-purity, deionized water in the internal water circuit. The use of this water helps to protect the catalysts from impurities, preventing degradation and the gradual loss of performance and efficiency.

The use of highly purified, deionized water also helps to ensure that the hydrogen produced is of a higher purity than other electrolysis technologies.

PEM or AEL
Fig. 1: The functional principle of PEM electrolysis

Advantages of PEM electrolysis

PEM electrolysis is designed for the production of particularly pure green hydrogen and offers many advantages over other electrolysis processes. In contrast to alkaline electrolysis, PEM electrolysis does not use chemical additives (such as aggressive chemicals as liquid electrolytes) and does not require complex post-purification of the hydrogen. In addition, PEM electrolyzers can operate at higher pressures. This increases the efficiency of hydrogen production and saves money and energy, by partially eliminating the need for further compression of the hydrogen.

At a glance: The advantages of PEM electrolysis over alkaline electrolysis

  • High flexibility and energy efficiency: PEM electrolyzers demonstrate greater flexibility than alkaline electrolysis, particularly in terms of load changes, minimum load points and cold-start capability. PEM electrolyzers can respond more quickly to changes in the power supply and operate more efficiently and, above all, more reliably than other technologies, even at low loads, i.e. with a lower power supply. Thanks to their high flexibility, PEM electrolyzers are particularly suitable for off-grid projects using renewable energy sources such as wind or solar, which are often subject to fluctuations in the power supply. In addition, PEM electrolyzers offer a faster response time, as the start-up time is shorter and they can be commissioned more quickly.
  • More compact design: PEM electrolyzers are generally more compact and require less space than alkaline electrolyzers. One reason is that PEM electrolysis operates at a higher pressure and therefore requires fewer compressors than alkaline electrolysis. Furthermore, PEM electrolyzers do not require tanks for potassium hydroxide (KOH), the electrolyte used in alkaline electrolysis. The compact design is particularly advantageous in applications where space for electrolyzers is limited. For example, a Quest One 1 MW PEM electrolyzer fits into a standard container. If the amount of hydrogen required each day increases, the system can be easily and flexibly expanded. The Modular Hydrogen Platform (MHP) (>>insert link) is designed for even greater scalability. Standardized blocks with an electrolysis capacity of 10 MW can be easily combined to form plants with an electrolysis capacity of 100 MW and more.
  • High-purity hydrogen: PEM electrolysis produces particularly pure green hydrogen, that is ideal for mobility applications such as  refueling fuel cell vehicles. In contrast, the purification of the gas produced by alkaline electrolysis can be more complex.
  • Simple service and maintenance: PEM electrolyzers require less maintenance than alkaline electrolyzers for various reasons. For example, they do not have large tanks for potassium hydroxide, which do not have to be emptied and refilled regularly. Due to the higher operating pressure of PEM electrolysis, fewer compressors, which are often susceptible to maintenance, are also required. PEM stacks are also often much more compact and more lightweight than alkaline electrolysis stacks. This means that maintenance work on individual stacks is much less demanding and, due to their size, has a much smaller impact on the overall operation of the system, for example through more extensive service interruptions.

Comments

No Comments yet.

Return to the blog

Write comment

* These fields are required